Oakland’s $2.6 Million Wake-Up Call: Addressing Workplace Sexual Harassment

Sexual harassment in the workplace is a reality that far too many employees face, and the recent $2.6 million jury verdict against the city of Oakland sheds light on this persistent issue. Harassment is often carried out by people in leadership positions, which makes it challenging for workers to report the misconduct or get it to stop. The case not only highlights the serious repercussions for employers who fail to address harassment but also underscores the importance of asserting worker rights. 

Patricia Toscano worked as an administrative assistant at the East Oakland Senior Center for around a decade. Toscano, who is the mother of former Golden State Warriors basketball player Juan Toscano-Anderson, said she endured years of sexual harassment from her male supervisor. Despite her numerous complaints, city officials failed to take action to protect her from misconduct or discipline the supervisor. 

Toscano’s ordeal began in early 2016 when her supervisor, Frank Knight, made unwanted advances, tried to kiss her, brushed against her inappropriately and made sexual comments. Knight was the chief of custodians at Oakland’s four senior centers. Instead of addressing her complaints, city officials ignored them and allowed the harassment to continue unchecked.

In 2018, an anonymous tip finally prompted an internal investigation, which confirmed Toscano’s allegations and highlighted the city’s failure to prevent harassment. However, rather than taking disciplinary action against Knight, the city subjected Toscano to harsh and retaliatory treatment. She was forced to transfer to another senior center. Feeling unsupported and demoralized, Toscano filed a lawsuit in 2021 and eventually resigned in January 2022.

The trial in Alameda County Superior Court revealed the extent of the city’s negligence and retaliation. Toscano’s lawyer presented compelling evidence showing how the employer failed to take appropriate action and instead retaliated against Toscano for speaking out about the harassment.

Toscano and other workers testified that Knight “created a sexually hostile work environment for years.” Despite that, Knight still held his supervisor position. The jury unanimously found in Toscano’s favor, awarding her $2.6 million in damages.

Sexual harassment in the workplace can take many forms, including unwanted advances, inappropriate touching and sexually explicit comments. It creates a hostile work environment that can severely impact the worker’s job performance, as well as their mental health and overall well-being. Despite laws designed to protect employees, many still face significant barriers when reporting harassment.

One of the biggest challenges is fear of retaliation. Workers often worry their complaints will not be taken seriously, or they will face negative consequences for speaking out. This fear is not unfounded, as demonstrated by Toscano’s case where her complaints were ignored, and she was subjected to further mistreatment. However, workers can obtain justice and compensation with the help of a skilled employment lawyer.

Employers are legally obligated to create a safe work environment. Some crucial steps include implementing clear anti-harassment policies, providing regular training to employees and supervisors, and taking immediate action when a complaint is made. Failure to do so can result in legal action, as evidenced by the Oakland verdict.

For workers experiencing harassment, it is crucial to document every incident in detail. Keeping a record of dates, times and specific actions can provide important evidence if the case goes to trial. Employees should also report sexual harassment to their human resources department or a trusted supervisor, following their company’s official procedures.

If internal reporting does not lead to satisfactory action, workers can seek external help. A reputable employment lawyer can advise the best course of action, whether it involves filing a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission or pursuing a lawsuit.

If you have faced workplace sexual harassment or discrimination, it is crucial to seek legal assistance. Erlich Law Firm has experience helping workers fight unlawful employment practices and hold employers accountable. An Oakland employment lawyer can explore your options for resolving your workplace issue. Contact us today for a free consultation to discuss your case.